Your AI Agents can now act on comments added in BugSmash with our MCP. See How it works.

BugSmash: The best BugHerd alternative

Client sign-off without asking anyone to install anything

BugHerd pins feedback accurately because it runs inside the page, which means a script on every client site or a browser extension for every reviewer. BugSmash reviews a live site from a pasted URL and carries the comment through to a ticket and a recorded approval, across thirteen file types.

4.8 out of 5 · 1,250+ agencies in 100+ countries

Knauf
Radancy
Frontier
City of Boroondara
Berlin Heart
GVBOCES
Bville
Frost Collective
Mediapilote
Medwiki
Musaffa
Sharp Guys Web Design

Loved by1,250+Agenciesand companies in 100+ countries

Loading testimonials

BugSmash is the closest BugHerd alternative for agencies that do not want a tracking script on client sites.

Both pin client comments to a live page and capture browser, OS and screen details automatically. BugSmash works from a pasted URL with no install, has a free plan rather than a seven day trial, includes Jira and ClickUp from $25 instead of $150, and reviews video, audio, mobile apps, 3D and CAD as well as web.

FeatureBugHerdBugSmash
Install neededA script on the site, or a browser extension for whoever reviewsNothing, widget optional
Free planNone, 7 day trial, no cardFree forever, no card
Entry price$50/mo (5 members)$0, then $25/mo (2 users included)
Jira, Asana, ClickUp, Linear$150/mo Premium$25/mo Starter
File formats413

What is BugHerd?

BugHerd is a website feedback and bug tracking tool. A JavaScript snippet on the site, or a browser extension, lets reviewers pin comments directly onto a page, and each comment becomes a card on a kanban board with browser, OS and screen details captured automatically.

It also reviews Figma files, PDFs and images. Plans include a fixed number of team members, with unlimited projects and unlimited client guests on every tier.

PRIMARY USE CASES

  • Website bug reporting and QA triage
  • Client feedback on a build you control
  • Kanban-style task management for web fixes
  • Figma, PDF and image markup

Why agencies move off BugHerd

BugHerd is a well built tool with a genuinely good price at the top of its range. Four things push people to look.

The snippet has to go on the client's site

BugHerd works by running a JavaScript snippet inside the page. That is what makes the comment layer accurate, and it is also a dependency: the code has to be added to every site you review, and it has to be taken off again before launch.

The failure mode that agencies actually report is not forgetting to add it. It is forgetting to remove it, and shipping a client's live site with a feedback widget still attached to it.

BugHerd does offer a way round it. If you cannot put code on the site, reviewing happens through a browser extension instead, which means whoever is leaving feedback installs something in their own browser. That works for your team. It is exactly the thing agency clients refuse: two of our own customers independently named asking a client to install a browser plugin as a hard disqualifier, on the grounds that clients hire an agency so they do not have to do tech.

So the choice is a script on every client site, or an install on every client's browser. There is no third option where the client just opens a link.

No free plan, and a seven day trial

BugHerd has no permanent free tier. The entry point is a seven day trial and then $50 a month for five members. For a freelancer running one client project a month, or a team that wants to pilot a tool before committing, seven days is not enough time to run a real review cycle with a real client.

The integrations you need are on the $150 plan

Standard at $50 includes Trello, Slack and GitHub. Jira, Asana, Linear, ClickUp and Monday are Premium features at $150 a month. For most agencies the project tool is not optional, so the real entry price is the top plan.

Member quotas, then per seat above them

Each plan includes a member quota: five on Standard, ten on Studio, twenty five on Premium. Past the quota, each extra person is billed separately at roughly $8 a month. Projects and client guests stay unlimited throughout, which is genuinely good, but your own team is still metered.

It reviews websites and not much else

Website feedback, plus Figma, PDFs and images. No video, no audio, no native mobile app review, no 3D or CAD. If the same client sends you a campaign cut or a podcast edit, that review happens somewhere else.

What does not change when you switch

The real worry about changing review tool is never whether the new one is better. It is whether your client will refuse to use it. Nothing you ask of your clients changes.

Still no login

Clients open the link and comment. No account, no password, no install.

Still one link

Paste it into the email you were already writing.

Still pinned to the page

Click the exact spot, type, reply in a thread.

Still folders and share controls

Organise by client, control who can view or comment, get notified when they do.

BugSmash and BugHerd: quick comparison

The short version. The detailed comparison is underneath.

FeatureBugHerdBugSmash
Entry price$50/mo (5 members)$0, then $25/mo (2 users included)
To start a reviewScript on the site, or an extension per reviewerPaste the URL
Before the site goes liveThe script has to come offNothing to remove
Free planNone, 7 day trialYes, no card
Jira, Asana, ClickUp, Linear$150/mo PremiumFrom $25/mo
File types reviewedWebsites, Figma, PDFs, images13

BugSmash vs BugHerd: detailed comparison

Grouped by the decision you are actually making, not by feature name.

BugSmash vs BugHerd: detailed comparison
FeatureBugHerdBugSmash
HOW YOU SET IT UP
Review a live siteJavaScript snippet on the sitePaste the URL, no install
Review a site you do not controlBrowser extension only, installed by each reviewerYes, paste the URL
Review a password protected or staging buildYes, via the snippetYes, via the optional widget
Something left behind at launchThe snippet must be removedNothing to remove
COST AND LIMITS
Free planNoneFree forever, no card
Trial7 daysNot needed, the free plan is permanent
Entry price$50/mo (5 members)$0, then $25/mo (2 users included)
Members included5, then 10, then 25 by plan2 on Starter, 10 on Team, 25 on Agency
Extra member cost$8 monthly, $6.60 on annual billing$5 each per month
ProjectsUnlimited on every plan50 at $25 unlimited from $69
Client guestsUnlimited on every planUnlimited on every plan, never counted as seats
Storage10 GB, 25 GB, 50 GB by plan5 GB free, up to 500 GB
WHAT YOU CAN REVIEW
Live websites and web appsYesYes
Figma filesYesVia the Figma plugin
PDFs and imagesYesYes
Recorded video feedback sessionsYesScreen recording available
Review a video file with timestamped commentsNoYes
Audio with timeline commentsNoYes
Native mobile appsNoYes
3D models and CAD drawingsNoYes
Email builds, slide decks, Word docs, raw HTMLNoYes
WHAT HAPPENS AFTER THE COMMENT
Trello, Slack, GitHubStandard, $50Starter, $25
Jira, Asana, Linear, ClickUp, MondayPremium, $150Starter, $25
Zapier, Make, n8n, webhooksZapier on StudioYes
AI on the feedbackAuto-title on every plan, auto-tagging and similar task detection on Premium, all betaAuto-title plus accessibility, UI, copy and broken link checks
AI review of the work itself, before a human looksNoAccessibility, UI, copy, broken links on every plan
Hand open comments to an AI agentYes, BugHerd ships an MCP server, in beta on every planYes, over MCP
WHERE BUGHERD IS STRONGER
Price at twenty five people$150/mo with 25 members included$129 on Agency, 25 included, with white labelling
Task board and workflow depthKanban built for bug triageLighter, built around approval
Accuracy inside complex live appsThe snippet runs in the real pageMatched only when you use the widget
Single sign-onCustom plan onlyEnterprise plan
Money back guarantee60 daysNot offered
Track recordLonger in marketYounger product

What you would pay

If this is youBugHerdBugSmashDifference a year
Freelancer, one client at a time$50$0$600
Five person studio, needs Jira$150$40$1,320
Twelve person agency, needs ClickUp$150$79$852
Twenty five people, needs own domain$150, branding included on Premium$129$252

The gap is widest at the bottom and narrows to almost nothing at the top. BugHerd is priced for a large team that has already committed, and at twenty five people it is genuinely competitive. If you are smaller than that, or still deciding, the entry cost is where it hurts.

View BugSmash Plans & Pricing

What you get that BugHerd does not have

Nothing for anyone to install

Paste a URL and start reviewing. No deployment ticket before a review can start, no snippet sitting on a client site waiting to be forgotten, and no browser extension for your client to work out. BugSmash has a widget if you want the in-page version for a JavaScript heavy app or a protected staging build, but it is a choice rather than the only route in.

Your project tool included from $25

Jira, Slack, ClickUp, Asana, Monday, Trello, Linear, Notion and Airtable, plus Zapier, Make, n8n and webhooks, on the entry paid plan rather than the $150 one.

Nine formats BugHerd cannot open

Video and audio with timeline comments, native mobile apps, 3D models, CAD drawings, email builds, slide decks, Word documents and raw HTML. One client, one workspace, one feedback history across everything they send you.

A free plan you can actually run a project on

Two projects, unlimited guest reviewers, unlimited comments, no credit card and no seven day clock. Pilot it on a real client before you decide anything.

When you should stay on BugHerd

BugSmash is the better fit if

  • You cannot or will not put code on a client's site
  • You review video, audio, mobile apps, 3D or CAD as well as web
  • You want to review sites you do not control, for pitches or audits
  • You need Jira or ClickUp without moving to a $150 plan
  • You want to pilot on a real client before paying

BugHerd is the better fit if

  • You have twenty five people and want a real bug triage kanban board
  • You control every site you touch and deploying a script is easy
  • Your scope is websites, Figma, PDFs and images
  • In-page accuracy inside a complex web app matters most

If you have twenty five people, you review web only, you control every site you touch, and you want a proper kanban board for bug triage rather than an approval flow, BugHerd at $150 a month is good value and a better fit for that shape of team. The in-page snippet also gives it real accuracy inside complex applications, which a proxy has to work harder for.

If you do not want code on client sites, or you review anything beyond web and PDF, keep reading.

Why are teams switching toBugSmash

Everything you didn't know you needed, until now.

Switching takes an afternoon, not a weekend

BugHerd exports to CSV, XML and JSON on every plan and has an API, so your task history can come with you. There is still no import into another review tool, so new work goes in the new tool. One extra step matters here.

  1. Start free and put your next new project in BugSmash. Do not move history. New work only.

  2. Send one client the link. No account for them means no email explaining a signup, which is the step that usually kills a tool change.

  3. Leave BugHerd running until your billing period ends. Finish the reviews already in flight over there.

  4. Remove the BugHerd snippet from every site as you go. This is the one piece of cleanup a switch actually requires, and it is worth doing deliberately rather than discovering it later.

  5. Cancel once the last review closes. Nothing is stranded, because nothing moved.

Other BugHerd alternatives worth knowing about

MarkUp.io logo

MarkUp.io

Simple canvas-style review on live sites, images, PDFs and video, with unlimited users on every plan. Pro is metered at 100 reviews a month and the next plan is $499.

Pastel logo

Pastel

The most reliable live website rendering in the category. Meters active canvases and charges per seat above five people.

Ruttl logo

Ruttl

Lets you edit CSS and content directly in the browser while reviewing, which is genuinely useful for small fixes. Priced per user.

Marker.io logo

Marker.io

Built for development teams that want issues landing in Jira or Linear with full technical context. Aimed at engineers rather than clients.

Ziflow logoFilestage logo

Ziflow and Filestage

Mature enterprise proofing, very wide format support, formal approval routing. Both start well above the rest and gate white-labelling behind a quote.

Still comparing?

We keep a page on every tool in this category, including the ones that beat us in places. See all comparisons

Questions people ask before switching

What is the best BugHerd alternative?

It depends on what you are avoiding. If it is the JavaScript snippet on client sites, BugSmash reviews from a pasted URL with no install. If you want issues syncing into Jira or Linear with deep technical context and do not mind a snippet, Marker.io is the closer match.

Get your unbilled hours back

Start today, it's free

Set up your first review in under a minute. No credit card, no onboarding calls.

BugSmash website review interface with comment controls